Minority Report

Staten Island, NY — every free forecast we can get, averaged to be a little more right. County seat of Richmond County.

Updated Friday, November 13, 2026. Recorded fresh this morning from five free sources, and graded later against what the weather actually did.

← All cities and the scoreboard

Thursday, November 12

High 60°   Low 48°   Rain 93%

Pretty close — fairly safe (highs spread 1°, rain spread 21 points, 4 sources)

Minority report — Thursday, November 12: the National Weather Service stands apart, rain 79% against a group average of 93%.
Thursday, November 12 — every source
SourceHighLowRain
National Weather Service—44°79%
US model (GFS)60°47°86%
European model (ECMWF)61°49°100%
German model (ICON)60°49°100%
Canadian model (GEM)61°49°100%
The average60°48°93%

Friday, November 13

High 48°   Low 36°   Rain 97%

Pretty close — fairly safe (highs spread 4°, rain spread 5 points, 5 sources)

Friday, November 13 — every source
SourceHighLowRain
National Weather Service46°38°95%
US model (GFS)48°37°96%
European model (ECMWF)50°36°98%
German model (ICON)49°38°98%
Canadian model (GEM)49°32°100%
The average48°36°97%

Saturday, November 14

High 46°   Low 35°   Rain 22%

They disagree — a coin flip (highs spread 2°, rain spread 50 points, 5 sources)

Minority report — Saturday, November 14: the German model (ICON) stands apart, rain 50% against a group average of 22%.
Saturday, November 14 — every source
SourceHighLowRain
National Weather Service47°38°0%
US model (GFS)45°34°8%
European model (ECMWF)46°35°10%
German model (ICON)46°36°50%
Canadian model (GEM)45°33°41%
The average46°35°22%

Sunday, November 15

High 48°   Low 38°   Rain 0%

They agree — trust it (highs spread 3°, rain spread 2 points, 5 sources)

Sunday, November 15 — every source
SourceHighLowRain
National Weather Service50°38°0%
US model (GFS)47°40°0%
European model (ECMWF)48°38°2%
German model (ICON)49°38°0%
Canadian model (GEM)47°36°0%
The average48°38°0%

Scoreboard — who has been most right (all recorded cities)

Scoring has started — every forecast is being recorded. The first grades land once the historical record publishes what actually happened (it runs a few days behind), and this board fills in from there.